Anyone checking on the Albion Hotel in Bayfield, Ontario wants to know whether it is open again, what shut it, and what guests have said about it. This page sets out the closure, rebuild and reopening record from dated local reporting and listed reviews. Exeter Today reported that the reopening celebration would begin at 6:30 p.m. on Saturday, 27 September 2025.

Last checked: 2026-11-02

Current status: Closed since 8 December 2024; reopening reported for end of September 2025 · Reason for closure: Roof collapse caused by ice build-up · Location: Bayfield, Ontario · Reopening led by: Jeff and Leigh Graham, per CTV News · Guest-facing features named in reviews: Bar and restaurant with food, staff and atmosphere praised

Albion Hotel Bayfield at a glance

1 Closure and timeline
2 Cause and building
  • The roof collapsed during an ice and rain storm, and the building dates to the 1840s and was over 180 years old (CTV News London)
3 Rebuild
4 Owners and reopening
FactDetail
LocationBayfield, Ontario
Closure start8 December 2024
Closure lengthJust over nine months
Reason for closureRoof collapse during an ice and rain storm
Building ageBuilt in the 1840s; over 180 years old
Temporary roofInstalled by end of December 2024
New roof reported11 March 2025
Rebuild scopeNew truss roof, replaced upper brick, largely gutted upstairs, redone dining room floor
Owners leading reopeningJeff Graham and Leigh Graham
Grand reopening dateSaturday, 27 September 2025
Room reservationsRestart after Thanksgiving 2025

How we researched this

Last checked: 2026-11-02.

Sources reviewed: local news reports from Ontario outlets, a hotel social media statement quoted in news coverage, a radio station’s reopening announcement, and older user-generated review excerpts from listing sites.

Date note: sources differ on whether the roof fell overnight on 7 or 8 December 2024. This page uses 8 December 2024, the date given in the initial reports.

No on-site visit, no owner or staff interview beyond quoted news reporting, no check of current room availability or rates, and no guest reviews posted after the reopening were found.

The bottom line: No on-site visit, no owner or staff interview beyond quoted news reporting, no check of current room availability or rates, and no guest reviews posted after the reopening were found.

Albion Hotel Bayfield closed: dates, cause and reopening

Closure date and cause

The roof of the Albion Hotel collapsed on 8 December 2024 during an ice and rain storm. The building was empty at the time, and no one was injured. The hotel said it would contact everyone with reservations and refund all room bookings made during the closure.

Engineers inspected the building after the roof was removed and found the walls and corners strong. Only the verandah had to come down. Early assessments had raised the possibility of demolition, and the inspection did not support that outcome.

Reported reopening timeline

Dated reports place the main steps in this order:

  1. 8 December 2024: the roof collapses during an ice and rain storm.
  2. Late December 2024: a temporary roof is installed to keep water out.
  3. March 2025: rebuilding begins.
  4. 11 March 2025: a new roof is reported.
  5. 2 August 2025: the grand re-opening date is announced.
  6. 27 September 2025: the grand reopening party starts at 6:30 p.m., with free admission and a street party.
  7. After Thanksgiving 2025: room reservations restart.

Shoreline Classics FM also reported the 27 September date. Tours of the remade hotel, with a limited menu and drinks, were planned for the reopening.

Booking check: Room reservations were reported to restart after Thanksgiving, which is later than the reopening weekend. Confirm current availability with the hotel before planning a stay.

What to watch: the gap between the reopening weekend and the restart of room bookings. Dining and bar service were planned for the reopening period, but overnight stays were not reported on the same schedule.

Albion Hotel Bayfield history: an 1840s building and its rebuild

Recent history before closure

Reporting describes the Albion as a historic building, constructed in the 1840s and more than 180 years old at the time of the collapse. Its pre-collapse roof used original cedar shakes. Shortly after the collapse, the hotel posted a message on social media:

Our hearts go out to our staff as they will also be impacted by this.

Albion Hotel, social media statement

A GoFundMe campaign was created to support the hotel after the collapse. One news report put a separate campaign for staff at over $80,000. That figure comes from a single report and has not been checked against GoFundMe records. For a different historic hotel, see The Simcoe Hotel Saloon and Eatery: Menu, History & Reviews.

Reconstruction and reopening

The owners, Jeff Graham and his wife Leigh, vowed to rebuild. Jeff Graham said the damage was less than the owners had feared:

There is damage, but not like we thought. So that’s a very positive thing.

Jeff Graham, owner, Albion Hotel

Renovations included a new truss roof, replacement of all brick in the upper portion of the building, a largely gutted upstairs interior, and a redone dining room floor. The owners fitted a steel shake roof to match the look of the original cedar shakes. All wiring, insulation and structural bones are new.

The exterior is the same. The interior looks a lot like it did before, we tried to keep that true, but all the bones, wiring and everything, is all new.

Jeff Graham, owner, Albion Hotel
Bottom line: The pattern: the exterior and the interior layout were kept, while the structure and systems underneath were replaced. The reopened building looks like the pre-collapse hotel from the street, but its wiring, roof framing and upper brick are new.

Albion Hotel Bayfield reviews: what listed guests say

What reviewers praise

The review material is thin and dated. Excerpts on a Tripadvisor listing cover 2013 to 2019, and one 2024 excerpt appears on MapQuest.

Positives in listed reviews

  • An older review excerpt, dated 2013 to 2019, calls the bar and restaurant friendly and mentions clean rooms and a rooftop verandah.

Trade-offs

  • A 2024 excerpt on MapQuest mixes praise for the atmosphere with complaints about crowding and average food.
  • The closure lasted just over nine months, and room reservations are not scheduled to restart until after Thanksgiving.

Limits of the available review data

No guest reviews posted after the reopening were retrieved, so the current guest rating cannot be established from the material reviewed. The excerpts date from 2013 to 2019 and from 2024, and the total review count is not shown. For a different hotel’s review history, see Algonquin Hotel History, Ownership, and Guest Reviews.

Data limit: Treat these excerpts as dated, user-generated comments, not as a current measure of guest experience.

The trade-off: the most favourable excerpts are the oldest, while the most recent excerpt reports mixed food reviews.

Frequently asked questions

When did the Albion Hotel in Bayfield close?

The roof collapsed on 8 December 2024, and the hotel was closed for just over nine months before its reopening.

What caused the Albion Hotel to close?

The roof collapsed during an ice and rain storm. The roof was more than 180 years old, and the building dates to the 1840s.

When is the Albion Hotel reopening?

The grand reopening was set for Saturday, 27 September 2025, with the official start at 6:30 p.m. and free admission.

Who is reopening the Albion Hotel?

Owners Jeff Graham and his wife Leigh Graham led the rebuild after vowing in December 2024 to restore the hotel.

What do reviewers say about the Albion Hotel restaurant?

Older listed excerpts from 2013 to 2019 describe a friendly bar and restaurant and clean rooms, while a 2024 excerpt reports mixed food reviews.

When will room reservations restart at the Albion Hotel?

Room reservations were reported to restart after Thanksgiving 2025, later than the 27 September 2025 reopening.

The bottom line: the sources show a roof collapse on 8 December 2024, a rebuild that kept the exterior and interior layout, and a grand reopening set for 27 September 2025, with room bookings to follow after Thanksgiving. Check current conditions with the hotel before planning a visit.

The bottom line: The bottom line: the sources show a roof collapse on 8 December 2024, a rebuild that kept the exterior and interior layout, and a grand reopening set for 27 September 2025, with room bookings to follow after Thanksgiving. Check current conditions with the hotel before planning a visit.