Finding the best hotel in New York City means weighing guest reviews, editorial awards, location, and safety—all of which vary significantly by neighborhood. This guide compares top-ranked properties across Manhattan and Brooklyn using verified data from review platforms and travel publications to help first-time visitors navigate their choice. The Michelin Guide currently lists 29 hotels in its New York Key selection, underscoring the depth of quality accommodation in the city.
Last checked: 2026-10-19
Compare the lowest rates and guest reviews. Many options with free cancellation.Check rates
Bundle flight + hotel and compare deals and rewards in one place.Check ratesThis link contains affiliate advertising. Prices and availability may change on the destination site.
Top rated hotel on TripAdvisor: Lotte New York Palace (4.5 stars, #1 of 55 five-star) · Boutique hotel with highest Michelin guest score: Virgin Hotel New York City (score 18.1) · Luxury collection hotel from Five Star Alliance: Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown · Design Hotels collection size: 300+ hotels in NYC
How we researched this guide
Last checked: 2026-10-19.
Sources reviewed: Official property websites, neutral review platforms (TripAdvisor, Expedia, Michelin), travel publications (Time Out New York, Condé Nast Traveler, Resident Magazine), and industry lists (Design Hotels, Five Star Alliance).
No on-site inspections, staff interviews, or personal stays were conducted. Displayed scores and rankings can change over time, so readers should verify current rates and availability directly.
New York City hotel snapshot
- Lotte New York Palace ranks #1 of 55 five-star hotels on TripAdvisor, based on traveler review volume and ratings (TripAdvisor).
- Virgin Hotel New York City holds a Michelin guest score of 18.1, the highest among boutique hotels in the city’s Key selection (MICHELIN Guide).
- Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown is featured in the Five Star Alliance roster of luxury properties in Manhattan (Five Star Alliance).
- The Design Hotels collection includes over 300 member properties across New York City, spanning boutique and independently minded stays (Design Hotels).
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| MICHELIN Key Hotels in New York | 29 |
| Five-star hotels listed on TripAdvisor | 55 |
| TripAdvisor Best Value #1 ranked hotel | Lotte New York Palace |
| Highest Michelin guest score among top hotels | 18.2 (Le Coucou) |
| Boutique hotels in Design Hotels portfolio | 300+ |
| Hyatt Regency Times Square Expedia rating | 9.2 / 10 (2,081 reviews) |
| Time Out New York guide | 30 best hotels (2026) |
| Oldest continuously operating hotel | Algonquin Hotel (1902) |
What hotel should I stay at in NYC?
The first question most visitors ask comes down to matching a property to personal priorities. The table below compares the five hotels that most consistently appear at the top of editorial lists and review platforms.
| Hotel Name | Category | Michelin Guest Score | TripAdvisor Ranking | Neighborhood |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lotte New York Palace | Luxury | N/A | #1 of 55 five-star | Midtown East |
| Virgin Hotel New York City | Boutique / Lifestyle | 18.1 | N/A | NoMad |
| Le Coucou | Luxury / Boutique | 18.2 | N/A | SoHo |
| The New York Edition | Luxury / Lifestyle | N/A | N/A | Madison Square Park |
| Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown | Luxury Collection | N/A | N/A | Midtown |
Top overall hotel pick
For a first-time visitor wanting the classic New York experience, Lotte New York Palace offers the strongest combination of location, heritage, and guest ratings. It ranks first among 55 five-star hotels on TripAdvisor and sits in Midtown East, placing guests steps from Fifth Avenue shopping and Central Park. The trade-off is a premium price band that places it squarely in the luxury tier.
Best luxury hotel
Le Coucou earns the highest Michelin guest score among New York’s top hotels at 18.2, according to the Michelin Guide’s editorial selection process. The hotel occupies a converted SoHo building and leans into a restrained, design-focused aesthetic. For travelers who prioritize editorial acclaim over review volume, this is the benchmark property.
Best affordable boutique hotel
Virgin Hotel New York City in NoMad holds a Michelin guest score of 18.1, placing it just behind Le Coucou but ahead of every other boutique property in the city’s Key list. The hotel combines lifestyle amenities with a more accessible price point than the five-star competitors, making it a strong option for travelers who want a distinct identity without stepping into the luxury pricing tier.
Best hotel in Manhattan for convenience
Luxury Collection Hotel Manhattan Midtown represents Marriott’s upper-tier portfolio in the heart of the city. Its inclusion in the Five Star Alliance list signals consistent service standards for business travelers and couples who value predictable luxury across a trusted brand network. The neighborhood gives direct access to Times Square, Broadway, and Grand Central Terminal.
The implication for visitors is that the choice between these properties rests on whether review volume, editorial distinction, or brand consistency matters most.
Pros and cons by hotel type
Midtown East / Central Park South (Luxury)
- Close to Central Park, Fifth Avenue, and Grand Central
- Highest concentration of five-star properties
- Strong police presence and 24-hour foot traffic
SoHo / TriBeCa (Boutique)
- Fewer direct subway lines than Midtown
- Limited options for large families
- Can feel quiet late at night despite popular days
Best for segments
- Luxury travelers: Lotte New York Palace offers the strongest TripAdvisor ranking among five-star hotels.
- Boutique hotel lovers: Virgin Hotel New York City leads the boutique category in Michelin guest score.
- Families visiting NYC: Midtown and Upper West Side hotels provide the safest and most convenient base for first-time family trips.
- Couples seeking romance: Le Coucou’s SoHo setting and intimate design make it a top pick for a quieter, design-conscious stay.
Does the Waldorf Astoria still exist?
The Waldorf Astoria is temporarily closed for a comprehensive renovation that will convert the majority of its hotel rooms into private condominiums. The project, widely reported in real estate and travel media, marks a significant transformation of the Art Deco landmark. A reopening has been projected for 2025 or later, depending on construction timelines. The bottom line for travelers: the building remains a major presence on Park Avenue, but it is not currently available for booking.
What is the oldest hotel in New York City history?
Oldest continuously operating hotel
The Algonquin Hotel, which opened in 1902, holds the title of the oldest continuously operating hotel in New York City. It gained fame as the meeting place of the Algonquin Round Table in the 1920s and maintains a literary and theatre-district clientele today.
Other historic hotels still standing
The Plaza opened in 1907 and remains a luxury landmark facing Central Park. The Hotel Chelsea, which opened in 1884, is currently closed for a major renovation but still holds a central place in the city’s cultural history. The Algonquin link provides a direct look at how these older properties compare in guest experience and ownership today.
Where to avoid staying in New York?
Neighborhoods with lower hotel and transit density
Most hotel recommendations concentrate in Manhattan and western Brooklyn. Parts of the Bronx, northern Manhattan (above 125th Street), and remote areas of Brooklyn have fewer established hotels and less frequent public transit service. RoomMaster advises that these areas are less frequented by tourists and have lower hotel density, which can translate into a less convenient base for a first visit. The pattern is clear: neighborhoods popular with tourists tend to have stronger hotel infrastructure and more consistent foot traffic.
What is the safest part of NYC to stay in?
Midtown, the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side, and Battery Park City are consistently described in travel guides and neighborhood profiles as very safe areas with high foot traffic and strong police presence. Times Square itself is safe but can feel crowded, especially late at night. First-time visitors should prioritize these areas for their combination of safety, access to major attractions, and density of hotel options. What this means for planning: choosing a hotel in these zones removes a significant layer of uncertainty about neighborhood conditions.
Understanding price bands in New York City hotels
New York’s hotel market covers a wide spectrum. Luxury properties in Midtown East, Central Park South, and SoHo typically sit above $500 per night. Lifestyle and boutique hotels in NoMad and Williamsburg often range between $300 and $600. Four-star properties in Times Square, such as Hyatt Regency Times Square, which holds an Expedia rating of 9.2 from more than 2,000 reviews, offer a more accessible entry point without sacrificing central location. No single price range defines “best” — the choice depends on how much weight a traveler places on space, service, and neighborhood atmosphere versus nightly cost.
Location and getting there
Each of the recommended neighborhoods connects to the city’s subway system, but travel times to major attractions vary significantly. Midtown East gives the shortest walking access to Times Square, Grand Central, and Fifth Avenue. SoHo and TriBeCa require a short ride to Midtown but offer a more self-contained environment with high-end dining and boutique shopping. Williamsburg, served by the L train, provides Brooklyn skyline views but adds 15–20 minutes to any trip to Manhattan’s core business districts. Choosing a hotel near a convenient subway stop is the single most actionable step for reducing daily travel friction.
Our pick for first-time visitors
For a traveler arriving in New York for the first time, the Lotte New York Palace offers the most reliable combination of location, guest rating, and luxury infrastructure. Its top TripAdvisor ranking among five-star properties, Midtown East location, and proximity to Central Park make it a strong baseline for comparison. Travelers who prefer a more boutique, design-oriented stay should look to Le Coucou in SoHo, while those seeking the strongest value per dollar within walking distance of Times Square are best served by the Hyatt Regency Times Square, with its 9.2 guest score on Expedia and 4-star rating.
“The Michelin Guide identifies 29 handpicked Key hotels in New York City.”
— MICHELIN Guide, hotel-guide publisher
“Hyatt Regency Times Square is displayed as a 4-star property with a 9.2 out of 10 score from 2,081 reviews.”
The bottom line: “Hyatt Regency Times Square is displayed as a 4-star property with a 9.2 out of 10 score from 2,081 reviews.”— Expedia, booking-platform listing
Frequently asked questions
What is the best hotel near Times Square?
The Hyatt Regency Times Square holds a 9.2 out of 10 guest rating on Expedia from over 2,000 reviews, making it the highest-scoring option immediately adjacent to the theatre district.
What are the most famous hotels in NYC?
The Plaza (1907), the Waldorf Astoria (temporarily closed), and the Hotel Chelsea (closed for renovation) are among the most iconic. The Algonquin Hotel is the oldest continuously operating hotel, dating to 1902.
When is the best time to book a hotel in NYC?
Booking at least three months in advance for peak seasons (spring and autumn) generally yields better rates. Rates also tend to dip during January and February, excluding holiday weekends.
Are there any all-inclusive hotels in New York City?
New York City does not have all-inclusive hotels in the traditional resort sense. Room charges are typically separate from dining, though some luxury properties offer packages that include breakfast or spa credits.
What hotel do celebrities stay at in NYC?
The Greenwich Hotel in TriBeCa and The Bowery Hotel downtown are known for attracting a creative and fashion-industry clientele, according to Resident Magazine’s luxury hotel guide.
Sources cited
- Time Out New York – Best Hotels Guide 2026
- Expedia – New York Hotel Ratings
- Hotels.com – New York Listings
- Condé Nast Traveler – New York City Hotels
- Resident Magazine – Luxury Hotels Guide
- RoomMaster – Best Hotels NYC Neighborhood Guide
- NH Collection New York Madison Avenue Review
- Algonquin Hotel History & Guest Reviews